This fic is the epitome of everything that OCD is not. Thank you for your example.

http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3369195/1/

Srrsly. It looks like she read a symptom list and has no idea that there's any variety in symptoms. Not everyone is OCD about cleanliness. Everyone has their own little habitthings - mine is picking dirt out from under my fingernails or at my skin (bad, I know). NOT EVERYONE WITH OCD ACTS THE SAME.

Besides, you can't diagnose OCD with a blood test, I don't think. It's chemicals in the brain. Imbalance of seritonin, I believe. Hold on.

"Today the community of scientists studying obsessive-compulsive disorder has been split into two factions by a bitter feud over the exact cause of the illness. On one side is a group who believe that obsessive-compulsive behavior is a psychological disorder. This group believes that OCD is caused when people believe that they are personally responsible for the obsessional thoughts they experience. This exaggerated sense of responsibility makes sufferers more anxious, keeping the distressing thought in their mind. They try to avoid this feeling of responsibility by performing compulsions. On the other side are scientists who believe that obsessive-compulsive behavior is caused by abnormalities in the brain. A majority of researchers now believe in this biological hypothesis of OCD."

There you go. And to continue:

"Is there a lab test for OCD?

No, for now there is no still no such thing as a Laboratory Test that will reveal whether or not you have OCD."


HA! SO THERE!

Sorry, this is one of my pet peeves.
Tags:

From: [identity profile] zorpisuttle.livejournal.com


...that fic also has no tension or conflict, except for the "My not-OCD is pasted on yey" at the end. :(

Have you ever read anything by Orson Scott Card? In the Ender series I believe there's one planet where they've made Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder into a kind of religion. It's passed genetically through the population or something (I forget the details) and those who have it are considered the equivalent of living saints. And then plot spoilers happen, and the result is an interesting moral/theological conundrum.

From: [identity profile] redsilkscarf.livejournal.com


Pssshttt, that's incredibly dumb. That author certainly looks like they did their research, which makes me wonder: why is it that authors like that don't do their research? Did that make any sense? Honestly.

From: [identity profile] youkokoenma.livejournal.com

Your STD test came back---I'm afraid you have OCD


I demand someone return to me the braincells I lost while reading that ficlet. x.X

I especially loved how the chick showed no OCD-ness throughout the entire piece. Then at the end--"Oh, and you're obsessive-compulsive." ZOMG NO! Most horrible thing EVER. >.>

And what's a "blood tighter" anyway?

From: [identity profile] gutterkitty.livejournal.com


Forgive me for posting, since I am not one of your friends, but I came to your LJ looking for your rant about the Starman (Tencendor) series as I am a member of the Tencendor community and just so happened to successfully be distracted by this post.

Now I have clinically diagnosed OCD. It is not a genetic disorder nor is it caused by abnormalities. It's developed after a person experiences a tramatic situation. Oftentimes it is a by product of Post Tramitic Stress Disorder. In my case, I developed it after being molested as a child.

I'm only posting this because I read the story and the author is an idiot. Plain and simple. I think I will write a very long letter about her inability to properly dictate a character with OCD and because what she does dictate is down right insulting to and for those who suffer with OCD.

From: [identity profile] minviendha.livejournal.com


It is not a genetic disorder nor is it caused by abnormalities. It's developed after a person experiences a tramatic situation. Oftentimes it is a by product of Post Tramitic Stress Disorder.

Not always. I have also been clinically diagnosed with OCD, and I've never suffered any major trauma. I think the explanation is that some people, because of an imbalance of seritonin, are more tended toward showing symptoms of it/having problems because of it, that may be triggered by something (child molestation in your case, and sixth grade angst in mine).

I've never heard of it in connection with PTSD...that's interesting. And probably true, too. But I do diagree that it isn't a genetic disorder - while it might not be "passed down" simply, the tendency does run in families, like a tendency to be alcoholic. It might show up, it might not, but it's there.

This is just my understanding, but I have been doing my research since my diagnosis...not that I'm an authority by any means.

By the way, on an entirely different note, how do you do the effect on your icon? It is very pretty and awesome. *is an icon dork*
.

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags